1991 E30 318i auto evaluation

ToKeN_za

New member
Hello Peoples

I have a 1991 318i auto sedan , she has a sunroof which doesn’t work, cracked rear bumper, front bumper trim piece has broken off but the bumper is fine, drivers side passenger door trim fell off on the highway but managed to save it and about 150k on the clock( the odometer broke last year on 135k so I’m guessing on the mileage I’ve put on her) . She’s had no major work done and still starts and drives strong. She has been in the family since new and I am the second owner who has brought her out of garage retirement. If I were to sell her what is a realistic number I should let her go for?
 

Trevan93

Member
It would be great to see some pictures of the car as overall condition and specs would be one of the drivers of value.

I had engaged with someone selling a '90 318i auto, he didn't have the price listed. I found out the price was at a whopping R130k. Absolute madness for a really plane jane e30.

The reality is that there are lots of people that are trying to pass off mass produce non special old cars as collectors items and stimulate the market. And it may sell at those prices, I'm not sure who is actually buying these cars at these prices though.

Realistically speaking and in my opinion, this is a sub R70k car, to the right person provided it is in original condition and there are no major issues. A little less for the general public. It is the 4 pot engine, automatic box, and from your description there is some work to be done, which in fairness is to be expected given age but does impact price.

Now, it is great that this is a single family owned car. It speaks to a level of care and love for the car. Although this would need to be backed up by service history and more importantly some sort of maintenance file/records.

Here is some data pulled from AI that can help frame the thinking when pricing your vehicle:

What makes the biggest difference?​

  • Originality: Original engine, interior, wheels and bodywork are desirable.
  • Body condition: Rust, accident damage and poor panel gaps can significantly reduce value.
  • Mechanical condition: Engine, gearbox, differential and suspension.
  • Mileage: Lower mileage with supporting history helps.
  • Model: A two-door generally attracts a premium over a four-door.
ConditionEstimated value
Project car / needs workR30,000
Running, fair conditionR65,000
Good condition, mechanically soundR95,000
Excellent, original conditionR135,000
Immaculate / collector qualityR175,000+
These are estimated market values, not formal valuations or confirmed selling prices.

For your car based on a few assumptions:


Estimated private-sale value

R65,000–R80,000​

Assuming the car is running, legally registered and has no major structural damage.

Suggested asking price

R89,900​

Expected negotiated sale
R70,000–R78,000
Quick-sale price
R55,000–R65,000

I'd take this with a pinch of sale of course as this is just AI pulling data from difference web sources on what cars are priced at, not necessarily what they sold for.


Good luck!
 
Top