sash said:
Beemerbro said:
Lol that's not true:roflol:
Europe has no motorplan but BMW has sealed for life oil here too, and throughout the world in fact
You should have a case against BMW and ZF, have you tried speaking to BMW?
No, I've never approached BMW about this because both the cars I had where autoboxes failed, I'd bought them as used cars, so they could argue all sort of things about how the car was cared for, how it was driven and so on by former owners so it could get complicated. But someone who bought a new automatic from them could have a winnable case I'm sure because there's enough data around the world to show that their advice on "lifetime oils" is wrong and unscientific. The manufacturers of the gearbox ZF themselves are contradicting BMW- that's evidence enough. I would have loved to take them to court if my circumstances placed me in that position but the people who could, just haven't bothered. I know some of their gearboxes are made by GM but the failures are same as ZF ones. Degradation of ATF is largely blamed for these failures in the majority of cases. I don't know what GM advises on their BMW autoboxes, but I've had several Vauxhall Astras using GM autoboxes and the manual recommends 40 000 mile ATF changes. I've never had failures on astra gearboxes and have had failures on 2 BMW autos.
The 330ci E46 I have had its transmission fail at 74k miles in the UK in 2010 and here they fail around that mileage(75-100k miles). It's now in SA now tho. I fitted a reconditioned one and its run perfectly since then and I changed its oil and filter this January and it was black but no metal fragments or sludge, and this car's in such a great state mechanically and aesthetically i want to see how long it will last as it's now 19 years old. Despite their bad oil advice, BMW have made a bullet proof car in the E46. For that I admire them deeply. :thumbs: