Nothing beats a Beemer!

[Caddy101]

I like the E46 interior. The E90 feels... unintended, like they were unsure and so they played it safe and as a result it came out bland...

The W204 is great, that interior is on point, especially the face lift with an AMG package... so delicious :inlove:

 

[Budleigh]

The facelift W204 has a much better interior - Merc learnt their lesson with the iffy plastics. I'd say it's easily a match for the last E90s. And it might not be quite as dynamic at 10/10ths, but for most people the Merc is still as sharp a driving tool as they'll need. Plus it rides better than the BMW. Horses for courses.